Heya riverbee,
I think I know where the communication disconnect might be. I am talking about my feelings on supplemental feeding. Just a bit in spring, in a new hive, or in a dearth or in fall, things like that. Like what yankee has right now with so many new hives. Supplemental feeding of this nature, in my opinion, is such a small percentage of a hive's total intake as to be meaningless.
Heavy feeding, feeding all year, feeding through winter for year long production, feeding while there are supers on, that type of feeding is a whole different beast and you're right, it's not meaningless. And I don't advocate that at all, and it's why I stopped buying mass produced honey years before I actually started keeping bees.
The impression I got from the discussion flow was that yankee seemed comfortable after a few answers to their first question about feeding. (They posted basically "thanks, I'll go feed my bees!") Then Omie posted about open feeding and pure honey, and it felt, to my reading, that yankee's next comment seemed a little more back to being slightly bewildered, with concerns about feeding and pure honey, and how bees may store sugar syrup to use later.
I did not want a new keeper to worry that if they used sugar water at all, like at any time of year, that the honey would then be unpure in their hive all year or that they could be adversely affecting other keepers with their supplementing, and then possibly stop feeding when bees really could use the boost.
So, I started my comment with trying to clarify 'open feeding' so that yankee would know what exactly was meant by that. And then I tried being silly about pointing out how small a percentage supplemental feeding actually is to a total hive intake for a year, in an effort to say "hey, it's okay to supplement them!" And I ended by saying that you shouldn't feed while a super is on, to try to stress I was talking only about supplemental.
I was not clear in my response, obviously, and I apologize for the confusion!